What is the difference between price reasonableness and price realism?
Price reasonableness asks whether your price is too high, and agencies check it on every contract. Price realism asks whether a fixed price is too low to be believable, and it’s used when the solicitation says it will be. Cost realism checks whether a cost-reimbursement estimate is realistic, and the agency can raise your evaluated cost if it isn’t.
You priced your first services bid low to win. Then the agency rejected it for being too low. That can happen, and it surprises a lot of new contractors. Agencies can look at your price in three different ways, and each one asks a different question. Know which one your solicitation uses before you set your number.
Three ways agencies check your price
| Price reasonableness | Price realism | Cost realism | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asks | Too high? | Too low to believe? | Is the estimate realistic? |
| Used on | Every contract | Fixed-price, when the solicitation says so | Cost-reimbursement, always |
| Your price changed? | No | No | Evaluated at probable cost |
Sources: FAR 15.404-1 · FAR overhaul. Checked Nov 6, 2026. Read the evaluation section to see which checks apply.
Three checks, three questions
| Check | The question | When it’s used | What can happen |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price reasonableness | Is the price too high? | Every contract | A price found unreasonable can’t be accepted as is |
| Price realism | Is a fixed price too low to be believable? | When the solicitation says it will be done | A higher risk rating, or rejection if the solicitation allows it. Your price isn’t changed |
| Cost realism | Is a cost estimate realistic? | Required on cost-reimbursement contracts | The agency evaluates you at its own probable cost, which may be higher |
Price reasonableness: is it too high?
The goal of every price review is a fair and reasonable price. Most of the time the agency checks this with price analysis. It looks at your total price, not your costs line by line.
The Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) lists ways to do this. The two it prefers are comparing the offers it received, and comparing your price with past prices for the same or similar work. It can also use published price lists, market research and the government’s own estimate.
When there’s real competition, your price is usually judged against the others. A price well above the rest is the main risk here.
Price realism: is it too low?
On a fixed-price contract, the agency doesn’t pay more if your costs run over. So why would it care if your price is low? Because a price that’s too low can mean you don’t understand the work, or that you’ll cut corners to make it pay.
The FAR says this kind of review may be used on competitive fixed-price incentive contracts. On other competitive fixed-price contracts, it’s for exceptional cases, such as when:
- The requirement is new and may not be well understood.
- Quality is a concern.
- Past contracts like this one ran into quality or service problems because the prices were too low.
Two rules protect you. First, agencies must judge proposals only on the factors the solicitation states, so look there to see whether realism will be checked and how. Second, on a fixed-price contract the agency can use what it finds in its risk rating or in deciding whether you can do the job, but it can’t raise your price.
In a 2025 case, the Air Force told offerors it would check the realism of each hourly labor rate. It found 25 of one bidder’s 129 rates unrealistic and left that bidder out. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) denied the bidder’s protest, because the agency followed the method the solicitation set.
Cost realism: is the estimate believable?
On a cost-reimbursement contract, the government pays your allowable costs. So a low estimate doesn’t protect the government at all. That’s why cost realism is required for these contracts.
The agency reviews each part of your cost estimate. Then it works out a probable cost, its own best guess of what your work will really cost. It uses that number, not yours, to compare offers. If you underestimate labor or skip a cost, your evaluated cost goes up, and you may lose your price edge. Contract types explains fixed-price and cost-reimbursement contracts.
Watch for unbalanced pricing
Even with a fair total, agencies check each line. Pricing that’s far too high or too low on some lines is called unbalanced. It’s a bigger concern when start-up costs, base and option years, or estimated quantities are priced on separate lines. An offer can be rejected if the imbalance is an unacceptable risk.
Price each year and each line to match the real work. Don’t load costs into the base year or the first line.
How to price so you don’t look risky
- Find the evaluation section. Look for the words reasonable, realism and probable cost. They tell you which check applies.
- Build from real costs: pay, benefits, overhead and profit. How to set labor rates shows how.
- Check the market. Compare your rates with past awards for similar work. Research the incumbent shows where to look.
- Explain a low price. If you’re lower for a real reason, such as a cheaper location or tools you already own, say so in the price narrative if the solicitation allows one.
- Pay your people what the job needs. A rate below what it takes to hire and keep the staff is what a realism review looks for.
- Keep lines balanced. Each line and each year should reflect its own costs.
Key terms
- Fair and reasonable price
- A price the government decides is fair to pay, usually by comparing it with other offers or past prices.
- Fixed-price contract
- You get the agreed price no matter what the work costs you.
- Cost-reimbursement contract
- The government pays your allowable costs, often plus a fee.
- Probable cost
- The agency’s own estimate of what a cost-reimbursement proposal will really cost.
- Unbalanced pricing
- When the total looks fine but some line items are priced far too high or too low.
Common questions
Can an agency raise my fixed price during a realism review?
No. On a fixed-price contract, the agency can use what a realism review finds in its risk rating or in deciding whether you can do the job, but the offered price isn’t adjusted.
What is probable cost?
On a cost-reimbursement contract, it’s the agency’s own estimate of what your proposal will really cost. The agency uses it, not your proposed cost, to compare offers and decide the best value.
Can my proposal be rejected for a price that’s too low?
It can, when the solicitation says the agency will evaluate realism and the low price shows a risk the solicitation lets it act on. Read the evaluation section to see how price will be judged.