A $5 million cyber settlement hits an HVAC and fire-protection company: 4 questions for trades contractors

· 4 min read

Sources

On November 13, the Justice Department (DOJ) announced that Johnson Controls and two of its companies, one in fire protection and one in security systems, agreed to pay $5 million. The work was heating, cooling and other building services, not software. DOJ said the companies didn’t follow the cybersecurity rules in their federal contracts. It’s the second case like this in two weeks, and a warning for trades firms that think cyber rules are only for IT companies.

What DOJ announced

  • Who: Johnson Controls, Inc. of Milwaukee, with its fire-protection company and its security-systems company.
  • What work: contracts and subcontracts for building products and services, including heating, ventilation and air conditioning (HVAC).
  • Which agencies: NASA and the Departments of Defense, Energy and Justice.
  • When: January 2018 to August 2025.
  • How much: $5 million. A former employee who filed one of two whistleblower suits gets $850,000.

These are allegations. DOJ says there was no finding of liability.

What the government said went wrong

DOJ said the contracts required the companies to protect government information. It alleged that:

  • They didn’t control who could get to protected information, because they didn’t know enough about their own computer systems or control them well enough.
  • Where a contract required National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Special Publication (SP) 800-171, the federal standard for protecting sensitive information, they didn’t keep a system security plan that met the contract’s terms.
  • They didn’t fully write or carry out a plan of action to fix the gaps.

That’s the same pattern as the $13 million ILC Dover case announced on November 3: a security plan that was missing or only on paper, and gaps with no real plan to close them.

Why a building-services firm had cyber rules

Cyber rules come with the contract, not with your trade. Two clauses do most of the work:

The two cyber clauses most contractors see
If your contract or subcontract has…You must…
FAR 52.204-21 (basic safeguarding)Follow 15 basic security steps on any system that holds federal contract information
DFARS 252.204-7012 (Defense work with controlled unclassified information)Meet NIST SP 800-171, keep a security plan, and report cyber incidents to the Defense Department within 72 hours

The first is in the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR). The second is in the Defense supplement to it (DFARS). Federal contract information is information the government gives you, or you create for it, that isn’t meant for the public. Controlled unclassified information (CUI) is a narrower, more sensitive kind that a law or policy says must be protected.

A trades firm can hold this kind of information without thinking of itself as an IT company. Ask whether you get building drawings, site plans, equipment lists or access details for a federal site. If you do, and the clauses are in your contract, the rules apply to the laptops, phones and cloud folders where you keep them.

4 questions for trades contractors this week

  1. Which clauses are in my contracts and subcontracts? Search each one for 52.204-21 and 252.204-7012. Primes must pass these clauses down to subs whose work involves the information. If you’re not sure, ask your prime in writing.
  2. What government information do we hold, and where? List the drawings, plans and site details you receive, and every place they’re stored or shared, including email and phones.
  3. Do we have a security plan that matches how we work today? If the 7012 clause is in your contract, you need one. A plan that describes systems you no longer use doesn’t count.
  4. Is what we told the government or our prime true? That includes any score you posted in the Supplier Performance Risk System (SPRS). If it’s higher than your real state, fix it.

For a longer checklist, see five things to check this week in our November 14 note. For the basic rules, see the 15 basic cybersecurity requirements. The pause of the Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) program doesn’t change any of this; our note on the pause explains why.

Common questions

I’m an HVAC subcontractor. Do these rules apply to me?

Only if the clauses are in your subcontract, or your prime has to pass them to you. Check your subcontract and ask your prime. Your trade doesn’t decide it. The information you handle and the clauses do.

Does the CMMC pause change this?

No. The CMMC pause stopped new outside assessments. The clauses already in your contract still apply.

Who can file a case like this?

Anyone with inside knowledge, including your own staff. The False Claims Act lets them sue on the government’s behalf and share in what it recovers.